by horsekateer
This is a super old thread and apologies for reviving it, but I had the EXACT same idea and was wondering if anyone ever started on this?There are some really good ideas here that I might hijack and try to create Gotham Horror. I've only played the AH base game and I figure starting with the base is a good idea to keep things simple.
Here are some ideas I like/also had:
Other worlds are just crime scenes.
GOO are the big Bat-villains
One answer I thought of:
The gun thing with Batman & Robin could easily be solved by nerfing them in the hands of "capes". So if Batman/Robin/Nightwing etc is using a gun it has a -1 or -2 penalty or whatever so those characters would never want to use them. Basically common items become regular human weapons and spells become super-hero bat gadgets that only those guys can use. As far as unique items go those can be items that fall in between, tomes aka "schematics", and elder signs aka "confessions".