by BTBAM
Are you saying an example of:If Maginos played in Chapter 1 and got the scorching wand, but didn't play the following chapter in which Tilda did get the scorching wand, and then they play a 3rd chapter again and both are in play, who would get the wand?
Because that sounds different than how you first asked it, and in any case, I'd assume you'd give it to whichever mouse you chose to give it to. If you want to write in a house rule that they can have duplicate items of the items that don't have duplicates, feel free too. However, the general play would be that there is one of that item, and only one mouse would have it unless it was unused.